Understand Difference

Shaping America: Puritans Quakers and the Path to Religious Freedom

The early European settlers in America had different reasons for coming to the new land. Some came for economic opportunities, while others were refugees fleeing wars and persecution.

Among these diverse groups were the Puritans and Quakers, who arrived in America in the 17th century. In this article, we will explore the Puritan and Quaker religions, their settlement in America, and their impact on American history.

We will discuss why they left England, their beliefs, and their attitudes towards other religious groups.

Reasons for Coming to America

The Puritans and Quakers were two religious groups that left England in search of religious freedom. The Puritans were a group of English Protestants who believed that the Church of England needed to be purified of its superfluous rituals and hierarchical practices.

They were unhappy with what they saw as the formalism of the church, which they believed was preventing individuals from having a personal relationship with God. The Quakers, on the other hand, were a Christian sect with a unique form of worship, which included shaking, shouting, and dancing during their services.

They refused to conform to the Church of England’s authority and believed in the equality of all people in the eyes of God.

Both groups faced prosecution and persecution in England.

The Puritans were not allowed to practice their religion openly and were subjected to harsh penalties, such as fines and imprisonment. The Quakers were even more severely persecuted, with many of their members being imprisoned, whipped, and even executed.

Therefore, the Puritans and Quakers sought refuge in the American colonies, where they hoped to practice their religion without fear of persecution.

Dislike of England Churches

The Puritans’ dislike of the Church of England was due to its hierarchical practices and the use of prescribed rituals that they believed had no scriptural basis. They saw the church as having been corrupted by the influence of secular power.

They believed in a more simple and direct approach to worship that involved reading, interpreting, and applying the Bible for oneself. Hence, they found it difficult to work within the Church of England’s structure.

The Quakers shared many of the Puritans’ objections to the Church of England. However, their attitude towards the established church was more radical.

They rejected the entire notion of a formal church structure and believed that there was no need for any intermediary between God and man. They believed that everyone had a direct connection to God and could communicate with Him without any need for priests or bishops.

Settlement in Massachusetts Bay

The Puritans arrived in America in 1630, settling mostly in Massachusetts Bay, where they established Boston, a city that quickly became an important center for trade and commerce. The Puritans were led by Governor John Winthrop, who believed that America provided a new opportunity to create a community of God-fearing people.

The Puritans were highly educated and placed a great emphasis on learning.

Education was compulsory, and children were required to study the Bible and other subjects in schools that were soon established all over the colony.

Harvard University was also founded in Boston in 1636, with the aim of training ministers for the Puritan Church. The Quakers arrived in America approximately 30 years after the Puritans.

They settled in Pennsylvania, attracted by the promises of William Penn, who was granted a charter to establish a colony where religious freedom would be guaranteed. The Quakers were welcomed in Pennsylvania, where they established a model community based on their principles of equality and pacifism.

The Quaker community was unique in that it allowed women to participate equally in public life, a concept that was quite revolutionary for its time.


The Puritans and Quakers were two important religious groups that played a major role in shaping American history. They were among the first European settlers in America, and their values and beliefs influenced the American way of life.

They came to America seeking religious freedom and created colonies that became centers of industry, commerce, and learning. They made significant contributions to American culture and influenced future generations of Americans.

Their legacy is still felt today in various aspects of American society and culture.The Quakers were an important religious group that emerged in the 17th century and had a major impact on American history. William Penn, a Quaker leader, played a key role in the establishment of the colony of Pennsylvania, which became a model community based on principles of religious freedom, equality, and pacifism.

In this article, we will explore the Quakers’ beliefs, their settlement in Pennsylvania, and their differences with the Puritans, who were another important religious group in colonial America.

William Penn and Pennsylvania

William Penn was an English Quaker who founded the colony of Pennsylvania in 1681. The colony was a refuge for Quakers who were mistreated and persecuted in England.

Penn, who was given the land as repayment for a debt owed to his father by the English king, envisioned a colony where religious freedom, pacifism, and equality would be guaranteed. Penn was an advocate for the rights of Quakers and other religious groups and believed in the importance of fair treatment for all people.

Penn allowed his vision to guide the way Pennsylvania was established. He established a government that was based on democratic principles and allowed for freedom of religion.

He hoped that Pennsylvania would serve as a model for other colonies and nations and believed that it represented the embodiment of religious freedom.

Views on Religion and Action

The Quakers’ central belief was that everyone had a direct connection to God and could communicate with Him without the need for priests or bishops. The Quakers saw equality as a central tenet of their faith and believed that all people, regardless of social status, race, or gender, were equal in the eyes of God.

The Quakers believed that God’s “inner light” was present in all people and was the source of divine guidance and truth. The Quakers’ views on religion were rooted in their belief that salvation was not attained through ritual or doctrine but through actions that reflected one’s belief.

The Quakers believed that actions spoke louder than words and that a person’s moral behavior was a more important indicator of their faith than their words or beliefs.

Difference Between Puritans and Quakers

The Puritans and Quakers had different views on religion, governance, and social issues. These differences led to tensions between the two groups.

Sinning and Blessings

The Puritans believed in the doctrine of original sin, which held that humanity was inherently sinful and that people were incapable of performing good deeds without divine intervention. The Puritans believed in eternal damnation and saw conversion as a central component of their faith.

The Quakers believed that everyone had an “inner light” that provided divine guidance, and that this light was the source of blessings and positive actions. The Quakers rejected the idea of eternal damnation and saw the absence of blessings as an indication that a person was not living in harmony with God’s will.

Church Beliefs and Services

The Puritans believed in the importance of sacraments, such as baptism and Holy Communion. They saw these rituals as a way of expressing one’s faith and seeking divine intervention.

The Puritans were hierarchical and had a formal system of worship that required the presence of ordained ministers. The Quakers, on the other hand, did not practice sacraments or require the presence of clergy.

The Quakers practiced their religion in a simple meeting house that was open to all. They valued silence as a way of facilitating communion with God and saw the act of worship as an individual expression of one’s faith.

Church Roles and Bible Functions

The Puritans believed in the importance of the Bible as a source of law and guidance. They saw the Bible as the final authority on all matters of faith and practice.

The Puritans had strict beliefs about male-only voting and hierarchical leadership roles within the church. The Quakers believed that women should have an equal voice and role within the church.

The Quakers saw the Bible as one of many sources of guidance and believed that the “inner light” was the most important indicator of God’s will.

Equality and Religious Discrimination

The Puritans did not believe in gender equality and did not allow women to participate in church leadership or public life. The Puritans were also known for their treatment of Native Americans, which was characterized by discrimination and oppression.

The Quakers rejected traditional gender roles and allowed women to participate in public life and hold positions of leadership within the church. The Quakers were known for their support of Native Americans and their opposition to slavery, which was not shared by the Puritans.


The Quakers were a group of religious reformers who left a lasting impact on American history with their belief in equality, pacifism, and religious freedom. William Penn’s vision provided for a new type of governance, which became a model for other colonies and nations.

The Quakers’ differences with the Puritans were significant and led to tensions between the two groups. Nevertheless, they both contributed to the development of American culture and society, and their legacies continue to be felt today.The Puritans and Quakers were two important religious groups that played a significant role in shaping American history.

They both left a lasting impact on American culture and society with their unique beliefs and approach to religion. This article aims to explore the contributions of Puritans and Quakers to religious freedom and compare their beliefs in terms of their views on God, education, equality, and the importance of action as religion.

Contribution to Religious Freedom

The Puritans and Quakers both sought religious freedom in America, as they had been subjected to harsh penalties and persecution in England for their beliefs. The Puritans’ religious beliefs were not tolerated by the Church of England, whereas the Quakers’ unconventional approach to worship and rejection of traditional religious structures and hierarchies made them the target of severe persecution in England.

Their arrival in the American colonies allowed them to practice their religious beliefs freely, enabling them to embrace and purify their society according to their religious principles. In this way, they contributed to the growth of a new social order in America that upheld individual liberty and religious freedom.

Comparison of Beliefs

Views on God

The Puritans saw God as a righteous and distant higher power, and they believed that individuals gained access to God through their religious beliefs and acts of piety. They believed in predestination, which held that God had already preordained certain people to be saved.

This belief made life in this world a preparation for the next, which fostered their emphasis on discipline and moral behavior. The Quakers, on the other hand, saw God as an intimate and personal presence, and believed that God was present in all human beings through the “inner light” – the divine spark within each person that guided them to make moral decisions.

This belief prioritized inner moral development and the cultivation of ethical behaviors as a way to manifest one’s relationship with God in the world.


Education was highly valued by both groups, although they approached it from different angles. The Puritans placed great importance on formal education that embraced the teachings of Good in the instruction of biblical texts and other classic disciplines, which they believed would enable individuals to gain a deep understanding of the scriptures and connect more intimately with God.

The Quakers embraced natural learning, a process that allowed for the exploration of personal experiences in developing the inner light. This emphasis on deep inward knowings as a source of moral guidance favored self-education, which relied on personal experience as a way to comprehend the workings of the world and the divine.


Both the Puritans and Quakers placed great value on equality, although their approaches were vastly different. The Puritans saw God as a just, powerful, and benevolent authority figure who established hierarchical structures, initially through the divine right of king’s rule, that was reflected in their religious and political arrangements.

This view of governance placed the male heads of families at the top of the household’s social hierarchy, and gave them voting rights that excluded women and the less-civilised immigrants. The Quaker’s belief in the inner light emphasized equality by the rejection of hierarchical acquisition of faith.

They believed that every individual had access to divine truth through their personal experience, making the exploration of the divine as part of everyone’s right. Their emphasis on the ‘inner light’ allowed them to stand against religious intolerance and socioeconomic privilege in the emerging American social order.

Action as Religion

For the Puritans, religious experiences emphasized obedience to God through piety and the structure. Their beliefs were visible in their religious practices and the deeds that they did as a result of their faith.

Their attempts at personal and social purification were central to their moral and religious attitudes towards life in this world. The Quakers’ emphasis on the inner light as the divine spark within each person along with their values of nonviolence, simplicity, equality, and social justice inspired collective action.

Their religion was one of deeds that would relieve the suffering of others and bringing relief to those less fortunate than themselves. This concept of religion saw their religious beliefs manifest in social and political causes as well in harmony with their inner beliefs.


The Puritan and Quaker communities played an essential role in shaping American history, particularly in the origins of American social order. The Puritans, with their emphasis on personal piety and intellectual attainment, laid the foundation for American higher education.

They also contributed to the establishment of American civic life that valued self-discipline, personal responsibility, and individualism as tenets of good citizenship. The Quakers, on the other hand, placed great emphasis on the inner light, equality, social justice, self-discovery, and personal change.

They believed in self- and community-involvement, stimulated through deeds and that the manifestation of divine through human action could create a community based on the principles of equality, nonviolence, and pacifism. Together, these two religious groups formed a unique blend of religious beliefs that impacted and shaped the emerging American social order in profound ways.

In conclusion, the Puritans and Quakers were two influential religious groups whose arrival in America shaped the country’s history and culture. Seeking religious freedom and a purification of society, they established colonies that upheld individual liberty and paved the way for a new social order.

While the Puritans prioritized discipline, formal education, and hierarchy, the Quakers embraced the inner light, equality, and social action. Their differing beliefs and contributions to American society have left a lasting impact, with lessons of religious freedom, equality, and the power of personal and collective action still relevant today.

Their legacy reminds us of the significance of religious tolerance, social justice, and the pursuit of inner truth in the pursuit of a more just and equitable society.

Popular Posts