Understand Difference

Unleashing Power: Subcritical and Supercritical Boilers Demystified

Introduction to Subcritical and

Supercritical Boilers

Boilers are closed vessels used to produce steam or hot water for various industrial applications such as generating electricity, heating buildings, and processing materials. The diversity of functions and sizes of boilers demand that the design and size of boilers be optimized specifically for their intended use.

Two types of boilers that have gained popularity in recent years are the subcritical and supercritical boilers. These boilers have revolutionized steam generating systems by working above and beyond the critical point of water.

In this article, we will define boilers and explore the science behind subcritical and supercritical boilers. What are Boilers?

Boilers are closed vessels that contain fluid and convert it into either steam or hot water for various industrial applications. The fluid in a boiler can be water, chemicals, fuels, and other materials.

The heated fluid inside the boiler produces steam or hot water, which then gets transported to the intended application through pipes. Boilers have been an essential part of the industrial revolution and are still widely used today.

What are Subcritical and

Supercritical Boilers? Subcritical boilers and supercritical boilers are steam generating systems that operate at different fluid pressure levels.

Subcritical boilers operate at a fluid pressure below the critical point of water, while supercritical boilers operate above this critical point. The critical point of water is an essential concept in thermodynamics, and explains the behavior of gases and liquids close to this point.

At this point, the temperature and pressure conditions are such that the gas and liquid start to become indistinguishable from one another.

Subcritical Boilers

Subcritical boilers operate at a relatively low fluid pressure below the critical point, typically between 165 and 220 bar. These boilers use water as the working fluid, which is heated until it reaches its boiling point.

The water boils, transforming into steam, which then gets transported through pipes to its intended application. Subcritical boilers are widely used in many applications, including power generation, heating, and processing materials.

In power generation, subcritical boilers are essential for generating electricity in a sustainable and efficient manner. These boilers also enable power plants to remain environmentally friendly by producing minimal emissions.

Supercritical Boilers

Supercritical boilers are a step up from subcritical boilers, operating at fluid pressures above the critical point of water. This means supercritical boilers can operate at higher temperatures and pressures than subcritical boilers, typically between 265 and 320 bar.

Supercritical boilers are fluid systems that use water in its supercritical state, which occurs when water is heated to its critical point at around 374 C and 221.2 bar. When water is in this state, it has properties of both gas and liquid, and the boundary between the two is blurred.

The supercritical fluid is then pumped to the turbines at conditions of high pressure and temperature, which generates the steam needed to operate the turbines. What is the Critical Point?

The critical point of a substance such as water is the point at which the phases of the material become indistinguishable. This means that the liquid and gas at the critical point possess the same properties, and it is impossible to differentiate between them.

The critical point is where the boundary between liquid and gas disappears. Substances that are normally gases or liquids alter their state at specific conditions of temperature and pressure.

When a gas is compressed, its molecule’s movement becomes more orderly, and the density and pressure of the gas increase. As the pressure is increased, the temperature rises until the point of liquefaction is reached.

Conversely, when a liquid is heated, its molecular movement becomes more erratic, and the density and pressure decrease. The temperature increases until the point of vaporization is reached.

The critical point is the point beyond which a phase can no longer exist.

Critical Point of Water

The critical point of water is at a temperature of 374.15 C and a pressure of 22.064 MPa. At this point, the water becomes a supercritical fluid, possessing properties of both gases and liquids. The phase equilibrium curve that describes the relationship between temperature and pressure is used to locate the critical point of water.

Conclusion

In conclusion, subcritical and supercritical boilers have revolutionized steam generating systems by working above and beyond the critical point of water. It is essential to optimize the design and size of boilers specifically for their intended purpose to achieve improved performance and efficiency.

The critical point of a substance such as water is the point of maximum temperature and pressure beyond which the boundary between the liquid and gas disappears, and a new state of matter is formed.

3) Subcritical Boiler

A subcritical boiler is a steam generating system that operates at a fluid pressure below the critical point of water. These boilers are widely used in various industries for power generation, heating, and processing materials.

Subcritical boilers typically operate at a pressure range between 165 and 220 bar, generating steam at a temperature of 540C.

Definition and Operating Conditions of Subcritical Boiler

Subcritical boilers operate on the principle of a drum-type steam generator. The working fluid, which is water, is heated to its boiling point, and the steam produced moves through the system to its intended application.

The constant evaporation endpoint principle ensures that the water level in the boiler drum remains constant, even as steam is generated. The supply of water to the boiler drum is typically regulated by a level transmitter that helps maintain the water level in the boiler.

Once the water enters the drum, heat is transferred to the water, which makes it boil and convert into steam. This steam is collected in the drum and transported through pipes to the turbines.

Mechanism of Subcritical Boiler and Its Drawbacks

Subcritical boilers rely on natural circulation, which utilizes the difference in fluid density to drive the fluid through the system. The heated water becomes less dense and moves up the risers, where it forms into a steam and water mixture.

The steam and water mixture flows into the drum, and the separated water flows through the downcomer, where it is cooled, and the cycle continues. One of the most significant drawbacks of subcritical boilers is the presence of bubbles in the circulating fluid.

The formation of bubbles can reduce the efficiency of the boiler system, leading to significant energy losses and costly repairs. Another notable drawback of subcritical boilers is their limited operation range, which makes them less flexible and less efficient than other types of boilers.

4) Supercritical Boiler

Supercritical boilers are steam generating systems that operate at fluid pressures above the critical point of water. These boilers operate at a temperature range of approximately 538C and a pressure range between 265 and 320 bar, producing steam with a pressure of approximately 250 bar.

Definition and Operating Conditions of Supercritical Boiler

A supercritical boiler is a type of supercritical steam generator that operates above the critical pressure of water, thereby simplifying the design and reducing the capital costs. Unlike subcritical boilers, the evaporation endpoint is variable, and the drum is replaced by tube banks, which minimizes heat transfer resistance and thermal stresses.

The tubes in the tube banks contain the fluid flow path, preventing the occurrence of bubbles in the fluid circulation. The water pumps that supply water to the supercritical steam generators increase the water’s pressure until it enters the boiler section.

The water is then heated using the latent heat of vaporization through the heat exchangers. The supercritical fluid flows through the boiler’s various sections, overcome by its high pressure that ensures its swift and efficient flow towards the turbine.

Mechanism of Supercritical Boiler and Its Advantages

Supercritical boilers use a feed pump to supply water to the boiler, which then passes through a preheater, where the water absorbs the remaining heat from the exhaust gases. It then flows through the economizer, where it absorbs heat from the outgoing flue gas.

Finally, it passes through the superheater, where it reaches its supercritical phase, producing high-pressure steam for the turbine. Supercritical boilers have higher efficiency than subcritical boilers, resulting in lower greenhouse gas emissions.

These boilers utilize less fuel and consume less water per unit of power generated. One of its significant advantages is that the supercritical boilers can efficiently adjust the flow of fluid, making them more flexible and cost-effective.

Conclusion

In conclusion, subcritical and supercritical boilers are significant breakthroughs in steam generating systems. Subcritical boilers operate at fluid pressures below the critical point of water, while supercritical boilers operate at fluid pressures above this critical point.

The operating conditions and mechanisms of these boilers differ, with supercritical boilers producing more efficient and environmentally friendly steam generation.

5) Similarities Between Subcritical and Supercritical Boiler

Subcritical and supercritical boilers are two types of steam generating systems used in various industries worldwide. While these two systems operate differently, there are some similarities in their operational mechanisms and constructional features.

Operational Mechanism/Cycle

Both subcritical and supercritical boilers work on the same fundamental principle of generating steam by heating the working fluid, which is water. The water is preheated in the economizer section of the boiler before entering the evaporator section.

The preheated water is then converted into steam in the evaporator section, which then moves to the superheater section, where it is further heated. The superheated steam produced in both types of boilers is delivered to the turbine, where it generates energy.

After the energy is produced, the steam then goes into the condenser where it is condensed back into liquid form. The water that is produced from the condenser then flows back into the boiler to continue the cycle.

Common Constructional Features and Equipment

Both subcritical and supercritical boilers contain basic constructional features like air preheaters, economizers, turbines, and condensers. The air preheaters are used to preheat the air that goes into the fuel combustion process.

The economizers are responsible for preheating the incoming water before it enters the evaporator section. Turbines are critical components in boilers that convert the steams pressure energy into mechanical energy, which is then converted to electrical energy through the electricity generator.

The condenser is responsible for cooling the steam after it leaves the turbine, thereby condensing it into its liquid form. Modern subcritical and supercritical boilers have a drum-less evaporator section, which increases energy conversion rates and minimizes thermal stresses.

Boiler feed pumps are also common features in both types of boilers used to regulate the water flow.

6) Difference Between Subcritical and Supercritical Boiler

Temperature and Pressure Operating Conditions

The primary difference between subcritical and supercritical boilers is in their temperature and pressure operating conditions. Subcritical boilers operate at relatively lower pressure and temperature conditions, with pressure ranging between 165-220 bar and temperature reaching 540C.

Supercritical boilers, on the other hand, operate at much higher pressure and temperature conditions. The pressure ranges between 265-320 bar and the temperature can reach as high as 538C.

These extreme operating conditions enhance the efficiency of supercritical boilers by allowing steam to have a high mass flow rate, increasing the electricity output.

Drums and Bubble Formation

A significant drawback of subcritical boilers is the presence of bubbles in the circulating fluid which can reduce the boilers efficiency. Subcritical boilers rely on natural circulation, which utilizes the difference in fluid density to drive the fluid through the system, causing bubbles to form.

These boilers have a drum-type steam generator that relies on the constant evaporation endpoint principle, which ensures that the level of water in the drum remains constant and the evaporating endpoint defined. Supercritical boilers, on the other hand, do not have drums since the evaporator section comprises tube banks.

These tube banks minimize heat transfer resistance and thermal stresses, which in turn prevents the occurrence of bubbles in the fluid flow. Superheated fluid in the supercritical boilers has a smaller density variation, reducing the appearance of bubbles in the fluid flow.

Conclusion

In conclusion, subcritical and supercritical boilers operate on the same basic operating principle of heating water to generate steam for power generation. They share the same basic constructional features and equipment, but supercritical boilers can operate at extreme temperatures and higher pressure, making them more versatile and efficient.

The significant difference between the two types of boilers lies in their unique operating conditions, with subcritical boilers operating below the critical point of water and supercritical boilers operating above it. Therefore, even their mechanisms and drawbacks differ, with bubble formation in subcritical boilers being a significant concern.

The development of supercritical boilers is a notable breakthrough in steam generating systems, making them more efficient, environmentally friendly, and increasing power output.

7) Summary

Subcritical and supercritical boilers are both types of steam generating systems used in various industries for applications such as electricity generation, heating, and material processing. These boilers operate differently, with subcritical boilers working below the critical point of water and supercritical boilers operating above it.

The primary difference between the two lies in their temperature and pressure operating conditions, resulting in varying efficiencies and capabilities. Subcritical boilers operate at lower pressure and temperature conditions, typically between 165-220 bar and temperatures reaching 540C.

These boilers use water as the working fluid and rely on natural circulation to drive the fluid through the system. Subcritical boilers have a drum-type steam generator and suffer from the drawback of bubble formation in circulating fluid, which can reduce efficiency.

In contrast, supercritical boilers operate at higher pressure and temperature conditions, usually between 265-320 bar and temperatures as high as 538C. These boilers utilize water in its supercritical state, where it possesses properties of both gases and liquids.

The absence of drums in supercritical boilers eliminates the problem of bubble formation. The absence of drums also simplifies the design and reduces capital costs.

Supercritical boilers offer higher efficiency and flexibility, leading to reduced greenhouse gas emissions and optimized power output. Both subcritical and supercritical boilers share some similarities in their operational mechanisms and constructional features.

They both follow a cyclical process of heating water to produce steam, which is then used in turbines to generate electricity. Both types of boilers include equipment such as air preheaters, economizers, turbines, and condensers.

The air preheaters and economizers play crucial roles in preheating the air and water respectively before they enter the evaporator section. The turbine converts steam pressure energy into mechanical energy, which is then converted to electrical energy through the generator.

The condenser cools the spent steam to condense it back into liquid form. In summary, subcritical and supercritical boilers are essential components of steam generating systems used in industrial applications.

Subcritical boilers operate under lower pressure and temperature conditions, while supercritical boilers work above the critical point of water. The key difference between the two lies in their operating conditions, which affects their efficiencies and capabilities.

While subcritical boilers have some drawbacks such as bubble formation, supercritical boilers provide higher efficiency, reduced emissions, and improved power output. Both types of boilers share common constructional features and equipment, including air preheaters, economizers, turbines, and condensers.

These features contribute to the overall stability and efficiency of the steam generating process. With advancements in technology, engineers continue to prioritize the development of more efficient and environmentally friendly steam generating systems.

In conclusion, subcritical and supercritical boilers are vital components of steam generating systems used in various industries. Subcritical boilers operate below the critical point of water, while supercritical boilers operate above it.

The difference in their operating conditions leads to variations in efficiency and capabilities. Subcritical boilers have lower pressure and temperature conditions, while supercritical boilers operate at higher temperatures and pressures.

Despite their differences, both types of boilers share common constructional features and equipment. The development of supercritical boilers has improved efficiency, reduced emissions, and optimized power output.

The advancements in steam generating technology continue to drive towards more efficient and environmentally friendly systems. The importance of understanding subcritical and supercritical boilers lies in their significant contributions to industrial processes, electricity generation, and environmental sustainability.

Popular Posts